How Generous Are You?

Do you think that you’re a generous person? For example, if someone had a life threatening condition would you dip your hand in your pocket to help them out? Would you cough up, say, £50 a week to give them a chance at a happier and healthier existence?

The latest proposal to help curb obesity is for YOU (the taxpayer) to pay for weight loss classes and/or meal replacement diets for those who are dangerously overweight; how do you feel about that? Apparently weight loss programmes and/or meal replacement diets are cheaper for the NHS to fund than stomach stapling and are definitely the safer and, arguably, healthier option for the patient but is it something that the taxpayer should be coughing up for?

You can say that obesity is self-inflicted and that any health problems result from personal food choices so why should you have to pay for someone else’s bad decisions? The problem with that is that, although obesity related health problems are a strain on the NHS, so are smoking related health problems, drug addiction, alcohol addiction, health issues caused by stress and illnesses that result from genetics or for no other reason than it’s just luck of the draw. At some point we will all need the services of doctors and nurses and, in the UK, it’s the tax payer that will foot the bill for our treatment.

What would happen if that were not the case for people who were morbidly obese? Some would argue that making life more expensive for those who are overweight with a ‘sugar tax’ or a ‘fat tax’ (higher prices for larger sized clothes) or the withdrawal of free treatment would improve their condition. Has that worked for smokers, drug addicts or alcoholics? No, so why would it work for any other kind of addict?

If the NHS wants to reduce their costs that are attributable to obesity perhaps they should consider dealing with the cause rather than the symptoms – instead of putting together programmes that recommend different foods or smaller portions, wouldn’t it be better to look at WHY people are over eating in the first place? Many of the problems with the body originate in the mind so why not start there when we’re looking for answers?

My feeling is that by concentrating on the emotional reasons for over eating as well as the addictive element, long term solutions to obesity could be found rather than people suffering the effects of yo-yo dieting or invasive surgery. Is THAT something that the NHS should be paying for? In my opinion yes but what do you think?

Should the NHS provide treatment for ‘self-inflicted’ illnesses? I’d love to read your comments



  2 comments for “How Generous Are You?

  1. May 18, 2018 at 11:30 am

    You are brave! Thorny topic. You could argue that sports injuries are self inflicted too. Nobody forces a grown man to kick a spherical bag of air round a field or jump off a mountain with sticks strapped to their feet😊. Or drive for that matter.

    However, accidents are one thing but deliberately poisoning oneself at somebody elses expense is another.


    • May 18, 2018 at 12:25 pm

      Thanks so much for your comment. I’m a little daredevil me ;O) The problem is that there are so many things in our daily lives that can potentially threaten our health – drugs, alcohol, cigarettes, processed foods, refined sugars, caffeine, food additives, too much sun exposure, exhaust fumes – the list goes on and on! We all make choices whether or not to partake of some or all of these things and all of them are a potential future additional cost for the NHS – how do we decide what health issues caused by deliberate acts should be funded and which shouldn’t? I think it has to be all or nothing…….x

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply to artyplantsman Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: